Birmingham Local Conservatives have accused Labour of discovering an interest in supported exempt accommodation only after losing control of the Council, as an internal audit exposes weaknesses in the oversight arrangements it left behind.
The report identified thousands of outstanding checks on whether vulnerable tenants were continuing to receive the care, support or supervision required for enhanced Housing Benefit payments. Council management has committed to clearing the remaining backlog of around 7,200 cases by 31 December.
The audit also found fragmented information about providers, insufficient oversight of long-standing claims and reduced capacity for proactive inspections.
Cllr Robert Alden, Leader of Birmingham Local Conservatives, said:
“Labour’s newfound concern about exempt accommodation cannot erase its record during the years it controlled Birmingham City Council.
“This backlog did not appear overnight. Neither did the fragmented oversight, the gaps in reviewing long-standing claims or the pressures that have pushed inspections towards responding to problems after they emerge.
“These are the consequences of failing over years to ensure that the Council’s oversight kept pace with the growth of exempt accommodation. Labour cannot spend years in charge while these problems develop, then present itself as the party demanding answers once it has lost office.
“In communities such as Erdington and North Edgbaston, residents deserve to know why Labour councillors did not secure the action and effective oversight their neighbourhoods needed when their own party had the power to deliver it.”
The audit found that the Council could not demonstrate that its additional care, support and supervision review had been completed for 72 per cent of the claims tested. Outstanding reviews do not establish that claims are invalid, but they leave the Council without the timely assurance those checks were intended to provide.
Auditors also found no dedicated programme of periodic reviews targeted at long-standing claims, including some that had continued for more than a decade. Information about provider concerns was held across different services without a single formal framework to bring together risks and identify recurring problems.
Cllr Ken Wood, Conservative Shadow Cabinet Member for Housing and Homelessness said:
“For years, residents have needed a Council that gets ahead of problems, protects vulnerable tenants and takes the impact on surrounding neighbourhoods seriously.
“Labour’s response cannot simply be to demand action from its successors without accounting for what happened on its watch. Its councillors should explain why these weaknesses were allowed to develop while Labour controlled the Council, and what they did to challenge them.
“The new administration must now learn from Labour’s failures. The backlog must be cleared by the promised December deadline, and every audit recommendation needs a named officer responsible, a clear completion date and regular reporting so residents can see whether improvements are being delivered.”
Birmingham Local Conservatives also repeated their call for the Government to implement the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023 and bring supported exempt accommodation into the planning system, including a requirement for existing provision to obtain retrospective permission.
Cllr Alden added:
“The audit reinforces our longstanding warning that councils need stronger powers to regulate providers and control the growth and concentration of exempt accommodation.
“The Government must implement the 2023 Act and introduce the planning controls communities need. Its review should identify further action, not delay measures that are already overdue.
“At the same time, the new Council administration must use the powers it already has and put right the weaknesses this audit exposes. Birmingham needs action from both the Council and the Government, alongside an honest reckoning with Labour’s years of failure.”
